Supplier invoices and the three-way match

Matching the PO, the receipt and the invoice before anyone pays.

Baca dalam Bahasa Indonesia

On this page
  1. The rules
  2. Tolerances
  3. The accounting
  4. Common situations
  5. In Voltrus
  6. Checklist

When a supplier's invoice arrives, the question is not "is this invoice genuine?" but "do we owe this amount?". The three-way match answers it by comparing three documents created by three different people:

  1. the purchase order: what the buyer agreed to buy, at what price;
  2. the goods receipt: what the warehouse counted in;
  3. the supplier invoice (in Voltrus, the supplier bill): what the supplier claims.

The company pays only for the quantity that was both ordered and received, at the price that was ordered, within an agreed tolerance. It is the single most effective control in purchasing, and the one auditors test first.

The rules

CheckCompareRule
QuantityBill vs receiptBill no more than was received, minus what was already billed and minus returns
PriceBill vs POBill price within tolerance of the PO price
Supplier and itemsBill vs POSame supplier, same items
TaxBill vs supplier masterPPN only from a PKP supplier, with a valid faktur pajak

A two-way match (PO vs invoice, no receipt) is sometimes used for services, where nothing is received into stock. A four-way match adds the quality inspection result. For stocked goods, three-way is the standard.

Tolerances

Prices on invoices rarely match the PO to the last Rupiah: rounding, small surcharges, currency. A tolerance avoids blocking every bill for trivial differences while still catching real increases. It is usually expressed as a percentage, an amount per unit, or both, with the more generous one applying:

  • PO price Rp 50,000, tolerance 5% or Rp 1,000 per unit.
  • 5% of 50,000 is 2,500, which allows more than 1,000, so the limit is Rp 52,500.
  • A bill at Rp 51,800 passes. A bill at Rp 53,000 is over tolerance.

What happens over tolerance is a policy decision: block the bill until the buyer and supplier agree, or route it for approval by someone with authority to accept the higher price. Never let AP simply accept it: the person entering bills should not decide price disputes.

Quantity has no tolerance in a sound setup. You pay for what you received; if the supplier delivered less, the bill is reduced or the rest waits for the next delivery.

The accounting

The receipt already booked the goods against GRNI. The bill moves the liability from GRNI to accounts payable, adds input PPN, and isolates any price difference.

Example: 100 units received at the PO price of Rp 50,000. The supplier bills at Rp 51,000 (within tolerance) plus 11% PPN.

AccountDebitCredit
GRNI (clears the receipt)5,000,000
Purchase price variance100,000
PPN Masukan (input PPN 11%)561,000
Accounts payable5,661,000

After this entry, GRNI for the receipt is zero, the supplier is owed Rp 5,661,000, and the Rp 100,000 price difference is visible as a variance rather than hidden in stock value. For foreign-currency bills, the difference caused by the exchange rate moving between receipt and bill goes to FX gain/loss, separately from the price variance.

When the supplier is subject to PPh withholding, the payable is booked net and the withheld tax goes to a tax payable account; see PPh withholding.

Common situations

  • Bill arrives before the goods. Do not enter it as matched. Hold it until the receipt is posted; then match.
  • Partial delivery, full bill. Match only what was received. Ask the supplier for a corrected invoice, or hold the rest until delivery.
  • Goods returned after billing. The return reduces what may be billed. The supplier issues a credit note (nota retur), which you record against the bill.
  • One bill for several deliveries. Fine, as long as the total quantity is within what was received.
  • Bill without a PO. For stocked goods this is a control failure; investigate before entering it. For services and overheads with no PO (rent, repairs, consultants), the bill is legitimate, but it is checked by approval rather than by matching.

In Voltrus

The checks run when the bill is issued:

  • Quantity: a bill from a PO can never bill more than was received (net of returns) less what earlier bills already billed (net of their credit notes). This is always enforced.
  • Price: a line above the PO price by more than the tolerance is a price variance. In Settings → Inventory & trading, the Bill price check card sets the tolerance (percent of the PO price and amount per unit; whichever allows more) and what happens over it: Needs approval (the default: the issue becomes a proposal only an admin can approve in Approvals), Refuse, or Allow. Defaults are 5% and 0 per unit.
  • Tax: a bill with PPN from a supplier not flagged as PKP is refused.
  • Amount: a bill above the Supplier bill approval limit (in the Approvals and limits card) can only be issued by an Admin; anyone else's issue goes to Approvals for an Admin to decide.
  • Posting: issuing posts Dr GRNI at what the receipts booked (the billed quantity at the PO price), Dr PPN Masukan, Cr Accounts payable, with the price difference to 5-9000 Cost Variance and, in foreign currency, the rate difference to FX gain/loss. Withholding tax set on the bill lines is deducted from the payable.
  • Bills without a PO: each line can name a GL account (an expense such as rent or repairs, or any postable account); lines without one are booked to Inventory. Bills from a PO always clear GRNI instead.

Faktur numbers from the supplier's faktur pajak can be recorded on the bill. After issue, the amounts are locked; corrections are made with a supplier credit note.

Checklist

  • Enter bills only from the PO's Create supplier bill step, not as free-standing invoices.
  • Set a price tolerance and keep Needs approval on, with an admin who is not the AP clerk.
  • Hold bills that arrive before goods; match them after the receipt.
  • Check that the supplier is PKP before accepting PPN on a bill.
  • Review the variance account monthly: which suppliers and items cause it.

Run it in Voltrus ERP

Everything in these guides is built in: documents that post to the ledger as they happen, Indonesian tax, MRP and costing, with AI agents that propose and people who approve.

See Voltrus ERP