Product costing, WIP and variances

Standard cost roll-up, work in progress and why actual differs from plan.

Baca dalam Bahasa Indonesia

On this page
  1. What goes into product cost
  2. Standard cost: the roll-up
  3. Actual cost: the work order
  4. The journals through WIP
  5. Reading variances
  6. Changing the standard
  7. In Voltrus
  8. Checklist

Ask a spreadsheet factory what one cabinet costs and you usually get the material price list summed up, plus a percentage "for overhead" that someone chose years ago. Prices get set on that number, and nobody finds out until the annual accounts that half the products lose money.

Product costing answers the question properly, twice: before production, as a standard cost built from the BOM and the routing, and after production, as the actual cost collected on each work order. The difference between the two, the variance, is where the management information is.

What goes into product cost

Under PSAK 202 (formerly PSAK 14, and IAS 2, which it follows), the cost of manufactured inventory includes:

  • Direct material: components consumed, including normal scrap.
  • Direct labour: the wages of people working on the product.
  • Production overhead: indirect factory cost (machine depreciation, factory electricity, supervision, maintenance), allocated on a normal level of activity.

Selling costs, administration and abnormal waste are not product cost; they are expenses of the period. That boundary matters, because whatever sits in product cost stays on the balance sheet as inventory until the goods are sold.

Standard cost: the roll-up

A standard cost is calculated bottom-up from the master data described in Bills of materials and routings. Take Cabinet C-200, costed for a batch (the costing lot size) of 50.

Material

ComponentQty perScrapPlanned qtyCostAmount
Steel sheet (kg)35%3.1518,00056,700
Shelf SH-0530%325,00075,000
Screw M4242%24.483007,344
Powder coat (kg)0.210%0.2280,00017,600
Material156,644

A sub-assembly made in-house contributes its own rolled-up cost, which is why the roll-up starts at the lowest level.

Labour and overhead

Minutes per unit = run minutes + setup minutes ÷ lot size. Each work centre has an hourly labour rate and an hourly overhead rate.

OperationMinutes per unitLabour rate / hOverhead rate / hLabourOverhead
Press (2 + 30/50)2.660,00090,0002,6003,900
Brake (3 + 20/50)3.460,00060,0003,4003,400
Paint (1.5 + 45/50)2.450,000120,0002,0004,800
Assembly (12 + 0)12.045,00015,0009,0003,000
Total17,00015,100

Standard cost = 156,644 + 17,000 + 15,100 = Rp 188,744 per cabinet.

Setting overhead rates

The overhead rate is a budget: expected factory overhead for the year ÷ expected hours at the work centre. If PAINT is expected to carry Rp 288 million of overhead over 2,400 hours, its rate is Rp 120,000 per hour. Use normal capacity, not the hours you hope for, so a quiet month does not load each product with idle cost; under PSAK 202, unabsorbed overhead from low production is an expense of the period.

Actual cost: the work order

Now the work order for 50 cabinets runs. The press operator wastes some sheet and assembly takes an hour longer than planned:

Standard (50 units)ActualDifference
Steel157.5 kg = 2,835,000165 kg = 2,970,000135,000
Shelves, screws, powder4,997,2004,997,2000
Labour850,000895,00045,000
Overhead755,000770,00015,000
Total9,437,2009,632,200195,000

The journals through WIP

Production cost accumulates in work in progress (WIP), an inventory account, and leaves it when output is received:

StepDebitCreditAmount
Issue materialWIPInventory7,967,200
Absorb labour on operationsWIPApplied labour895,000
Absorb overhead on operationsWIPApplied overhead770,000
Receive 50 cabinets at standardInventoryWIP9,437,200
Close the work orderProduction varianceWIP195,000

After the close, WIP for this order is zero: 9,632,200 in, 9,437,200 + 195,000 out.

Applied labour and Applied overhead are credit balances that offset the real wage and factory expense accounts. If the factory actually spent more on overhead in the month than all work orders absorbed, the net of the two shows under-absorbed overhead, a period cost to investigate (low volume, or rates set too low).

Reading variances

A variance is a question, not a verdict. The usual breakdown:

VarianceFormulaTypical cause
Material price(actual price − standard price) × actual qtySupplier price change, rush buying, freight
Material usage(actual qty − standard qty) × standard priceScrap, wrong BOM, theft, backflush errors
Labour efficiency(actual hours − standard hours) × standard rateSlow run, rework, wrong routing time
Labour rate(actual rate − standard rate) × actual hoursOvertime, wage increases
OverheadAbsorbed vs actual overheadVolume differs from plan, cost overruns

In the example, the 135,000 is a material usage variance (7.5 kg extra steel) and the 60,000 is labour and overhead efficiency (one extra hour of assembly). Under standard costing, the material price variance is caught earlier, at goods receipt: stock goes in at standard and the price difference goes straight to variance. If the supplier's bill then differs from the PO price, that difference also goes to variance when the bill clears GRNI, under every costing method. See Inventory valuation.

Changing the standard

Standards are usually updated once a year, or when a large price change makes them meaningless. The update has an accounting effect: stock already on hand must be revalued from the old standard to the new one. SAP calls this mark and release; the same idea applies everywhere:

  1. Run the roll-up and review the new estimates (draft).
  2. Mark the estimates you accept.
  3. Release them: the item's cost changes and stock on hand is revalued, the difference going to a revaluation account.

Work orders already open keep the cost their material was issued at; the difference shows in their variance when they close.

In Voltrus

Things to know: Voltrus posts the whole difference to one production variance account; the price, usage and efficiency split above is analysis you do from the work order's cost panel. Under moving average or FIFO, output is also received at the item's current cost rather than at the order's actual cost, with the difference in variance, which is another reason to use standard costing in a factory. Payroll is not in Voltrus, so actual wages reach the ledger by manual journal or import from your payroll system.

Checklist

  • Every purchased component has a cost; every work centre has labour and overhead rates.
  • Overhead rates are budget ÷ normal hours, reviewed yearly.
  • Costing lot sizes match the batches you run.
  • Work order variances above a threshold are explained within a week.
  • Standards are rolled up, reviewed and released at a fixed time each year.

Run it in Voltrus ERP

Everything in these guides is built in: documents that post to the ledger as they happen, Indonesian tax, MRP and costing, with AI agents that propose and people who approve.

See Voltrus ERP